I couldn't write yesterday since emotion was raw and I was too tense and frustrated about this; I'm sure my face was a stormcloud during the MYC lesson.
Yesterday's piano lessons were probably the least enjoyable of the bunch we've had so far this fall. Why? Because although K arrived early and spent an extra half hour with Nicholas she said she doesn't see the need for it. That she had spoken to her director and that person has told her not to give in with doing the MYC programme at the pace it's meant to go at because there will be gaps later on. Fine. I can see the logic in that. She says she has kids who have come from other teachers and there are definitely gaps in their learning so they are having to work on those things. She said that Andrew and Nicholas both have lots of gaps. I just about laughed right there. Guess who their teacher has been since they started piano lessons a few years ago?!
She will do one more extra lesson with Nicholas in two weeks and if he hasn't shown a huge improvement she won't do them any more. Huh? I'm wondering what kind of huge improvement she wants out of him since this was the first private lesson he's had in more than a month! The music she had him playing was all new to him...how can he do anything but improve before the next lesson?
Next was Andrew's lesson and although he has been practicing and practicing and practicing for hours, it wasn't good enough. Why? Because he didn't spend as much time on
one particular piece out of the bunch that she had asked him to work on. He said right there that while he had practiced it, he probably didn't spend enough time on it, not as much as the others. Okay, but she didn't say anything about how everything else is sounding, just kept being very negative about what was not done. Oh, and the amount of time he should be practicing has now gone to five minutes
in total for all his other pieces and the rest of the time should be spent on the last piece. We're still not sure exactly what theory he should be practicing. The best part was she told me, in front of all three kids, that she has told both boys that she was considering getting in her car and leaving and not coming back until they agree to work harder. Yikes. I felt my blood start to boil at that moment. I didn't know what to say. I was shocked that the effort they have put into their music over the last weeks is not good enough! Seriously, these kids have been doing even more time at the piano than ever before, including Matthew (and me for most of both Nick's and Matt's practices).
When we got to the MYC lesson, Andrew was asked to stay in again this week "because he doesn't know his notes well enough." As we're going through the beginning stuff, she's getting annoyed that they don't automatically know where notes are on the staff, where they are on the piano, without having to rely on placement of other notes in relation to the one they are being asked to point out. Matthew was really struggling with this one, while Nicholas was getting them right on his tin sheet (a metal sheet with a keyboard printed on one side and blank music staffs on the other on which they use magnets to place notes or identify keys) the majority of the time. She expected Matthew to know the difference between where high C is and where low C is, and other notes in between. Here's the interesting part though...she hadn't taught them this specifically!
She kept implying that it was my fault they didn't know these things. That they couldn't read music flawlessly, couldn't walk up to the piano and find a note without hesitating, didn't know where high notes were found or low notes, didn't correct her less than perfect drawing of the treble and bass clefs on a wipe off board (I'm actually serious about that last one, believe it or not...they've never been asked to draw one before - ever - yet she said they should have told her that they weren't perfect), that I don't spend time with them at the piano. I'm more than a little offended. I have put a lot of time and effort into teaching
myself this stuff just so that I can help my kids! I spend time with them going through each piece she has asked them to do. I sit right beside them at the piano, pointing to the music to help them follow along. We practice where the notes are. I'm asking them to practice more than I think is necessary because she's the
teacher and knows these things, right?
I've paid until the end of November, including the next extra lesson for Nicholas. I really don't know what we'll do after that.
Sigh.